Salmon smolts in dammed rivers have a higher survival rate than a free flowing watershed?
Surprisingly, smolts fared just as well negotiating the heavily dammed Columbia as they did going down the free-flowing Fraser. Comparing the rivers section by section, Chinook smolts traversing the dammed system actually had higher survival rates than their cousins in the Fraser. Adjusting estimates to consider the distance and time smolts had to migrate to reach the river mouth revealed that average survival rates were much higher for both species from the Snake River than for those in the undammed Fraser. In fact, no matter how they analyzed the data, the researchers reported, “survival is not worse in the Columbia despite the presence of an extensive network of dams.”
Plos Biology has published a paper outlining a recent study of downstream migrating salmon smolts that suggests dammed rivers enhance the survival rate of ocean-bound fish. A combination of factors are mentioned, but no conclusions are drawn.
A synopsis of the article has also been posted, absent the graphs and methodology.
They found some of the salmon – most just the length of a hot dog – could swim distances up to 2,500 kilometres in only a matter months, putting their pace at about a ‘Phelpsian’ two body lengths a second – a reference the researchers made to the record-setting Olympic swimmer Michael Phelps.
Considering Michael Phelps only had to keep it up for a minute or two, that’s some powerful biological programming.
Pingback: Running downhill is easier, the Michael Phelps fish | catveranda.com
This study’s been the target of a lot of invective from other scientists, including a few who actually worked on it.
Some of it is no doubt ideologically driven, but some of it seems to have more teeth. One scientist noted that the Fraser numbers couldn’t be right – they suggested a population headed for extinction, and soon.
Another pointed out that most of the “study” was in fact a lengthy advertisement for the author’s expensive fish tracking system, which doesn’t necessarily engender confidence.